The regulation of genetic technologies

Closes 17 Mar 2021

Opened 7 Jan 2021

Overview

This consultation is about the regulation of genetic technologies.

It mainly focuses on the regulation of gene edited (GE) organisms possessing genetic changes which could have been introduced by traditional breeding. This is covered in part 1 of the consultation.

In part 2 of the consultation, we are using this opportunity to engage separately and start gathering views on the wider regulatory framework governing genetically modified organisms (GMOs).

Depending on the results of part 1, Defra may change the legislation to amend the definition of a GMO as it applies in England. Currently GMOs are defined in section 106 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990[1].  This would mean that this legislation does not apply to organisms produced by gene editing (GE) and other genetic technologies if they could have been developed using traditional breeding methods.

The responses from part 2 of the consultation will be used to inform policy development and stakeholder engagement plans on any potential wider GMO reform.


[1] as amended by regulation 4 of the Genetically Modified Organisms (Deliberate Release) Regulations 2002 (SI 2002/2443); techniques of GM are described in regulation 5 of that SI

Why we are consulting

EU legislation controlling the use of GMOs was retained in the UK at the end of the transition period (after 31 December 2020). This retained legislation requires that all GE organisms are classified as GMOs irrespective of whether they could be produced by traditional breeding methods[1]. Defra’s view is that organisms produced by GE or by other genetic technologies should not be regulated as GMOs if they could have been produced by traditional breeding methods. Leaving the EU provides an opportunity to consult on the implications of addressing this issue. We recognise there is a spectrum of opinions on these topics, and we are consulting to provide an opportunity for all views to be shared.

We welcome your response to the questions in this consultation and thank you in advance for providing your views.

How to respond

The consultation document is available to view and download at the bottom of this page. You should refer to it when providing your response.

We encourage respondents to provide not just their opinions but also the supporting facts and reasoning to inform the evidence base for the development of final proposals.

Please respond by 23:59 on Wednesday 17 March 2021.

You can provide your response via the online survey by clicking the button below. You can also respond by email: consultationreply@defra.gov.uk or by post to the address below:

Consultation Coordinator, Defra, 2nd Floor, Foss House, Kings Pool, 1-2 Peasholme Green, York, YO1 7PX

In accordance with standard principles we intend to publish a response to the consultation within 3 months of it closing.

[1] C-528/16 - Confédération paysanne and Others

 

Give Us Your Views

Audiences

  • Anyone from any background

Interests

  • Natural environment
  • Local nature partnerships
  • Biodiversity
  • Plants
  • Animals
  • Tree and plant health
  • Climate change
  • Green infrastructure
  • Ecosystems services
  • Deforestation
  • Illegal logging
  • Palm oil
  • Green economy
  • Sustainable development
  • National Adaptation Programme
  • Flooding
  • Flood insurance
  • Flood emergency
  • Marine
  • Marine Conservation Zones
  • Marine licensing
  • Common Fisheries Policy
  • Fish stocks
  • Shellfish
  • Sea angling
  • Waste and recycling
  • Water quality
  • Air quality
  • Water Bill
  • Water conservation
  • Bathing waters
  • Sewerage
  • Air pollution
  • Ozone
  • Chemicals and pesticides
  • Noise
  • Genetic Modification (GM)
  • Local environments
  • Aarhus Convention
  • Resource Efficiency
  • Pollution Sector
  • Science
  • Conservation
  • Water Abstraction
  • Holiday Accommodation
  • Domestic Waste Water Systems
  • House Building and Planning
  • Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases
  • Inland waterways
  • Construction
  • Watercourse maintenance
  • Water Act
  • Marine Conservation
  • Consultations
  • Impact Assessments
  • DEFRA Policy
  • Water Industry charging
  • Water Industry licencing
  • Policy and Delivery
  • Disability Access
  • Food labelling
  • Food standards
  • Egg industry
  • Poultry industry
  • Dairy industry
  • Wine industry
  • Protected food names
  • Food imports
  • Food and drink exports
  • Cattle
  • Pigs
  • Poultry
  • Sheep and goats
  • Animal diseases
  • Animal welfare
  • Livestock identification and movement
  • Growing and crops
  • Bee health
  • Peat
  • Marine fisheries
  • Farm management
  • Single Payment Scheme (SPS)
  • Cross compliance
  • Common Agricultural Reform (CAP)
  • Skills, education, training and new entrants
  • Land management
  • Nitrates and watercourses
  • Environmental Stewardship
  • Uplands
  • Soil
  • Shellfish
  • Forestry
  • Retailers
  • Livestock disease control
  • Sheep, goat and deer production/marketing
  • Meat Industry
  • Access to countryside and coast
  • Hunting with dogs
  • Inland waterways
  • Rural economy and communities
  • Rural broadband
  • Rural grants and funding
  • Rural Development Programme for England
  • Forestry
  • National Parks
  • Nature reserves
  • Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty
  • Common land
  • Conservation
  • Towns and village greens
  • Industry organisations representing tenant farmers and landlords
  • Solicitors specialising in agricultural law
  • Rural Properties
  • Recreational sector
  • Pets
  • Travelling with pets
  • Quarantine
  • Protecting pets from cruelty
  • Horses
  • Dangerous dogs
  • Wildlife crime
  • Wildlife management
  • Protecting wildlife
  • Non-native species
  • Whales and dolphins
  • Circus animals
  • Zoos
  • Dangerous and wild animals
  • Pet Travel
  • Pet Ownership
  • Pet Health